مرکز منطقه ای اطلاع رسانی علوم و فناوری خردنامه صدرا 1560-0874 22 4 2017 11 20 A Study of the Principle of Nobler Possibility and its Relationship with the Principiality of Existence بررسي قاعدۀ امكان اشرف و نسبت آن با اصالت وجود 85 98 fa حسن سعيدي امير اوسطي 2017 11 21 The principle of nobler possibility is one of the important principles of Illuminationist philosophy. Suhrawardi paid particular attention to this principle and sought to substantiate it in most of his works. The main purpose of this paper is to investigate the relationship between the principle of nobler possibility and the principiality of existence. Accordingly, the authors found it necessary to provide some answers to the following questions: Is the famous argument for the principle of nobler possibility which has been propounded in the works of Suhrawardi and his followers based on the principiality of quiddity? What is the standpoint of Mulla Sadra, as the founder of the philosophical principle of the principiality of existence, regarding the mentioned principle and the related argument? Has anyone ever presented an interpretation of the principle of nobler possibility based on the principiality of existence? What are the strengths and weak points of the interpretations of this principle and the related arguments? On the other hand, some objections have been advanced against this principle which can be removed based on the fundamental principles of the Transcendent Philosophy. For example, Muhaqqiq Dawani has referred to a problem regarding this principle which Mulla Sadra has resolved relying on the principiality of existence and the related principles. His response could provide the basis for a different interpretation of the principle of nobler possibility, which has been tackled in this paper. قاعدة امكان اشرف از قواعد مهم فلسفة اشراق است. شيخ اشراق، اهتمام ويژه‌يي به اين قاعده داشته است و در اكثر آثار خود بر اين قاعده اقامة استدلال كرده است. هدف اصلي ما در اين نوشتار بررسي نسبت قاعدة امكان اشرف با اصالت وجود است. بدين‌منظور، لازم است به اين پرسشها پاسخ داده شود: آيا برهان مشهور اين قاعده كه در آثار سهروردي و پيروان او مطرح شده، بر اصالت ماهيت مبتني است؟ موضع ملاصدرا بعنوان مؤسس فلسفة اصالت وجودي، در قبال اين قاعده و برهان آن چيست؟ آيا تاكنون تقريري از قاعدة امكان اشرف با ابتناء بر اصالت وجود ارائه شده است؟ نقاط قوت و ضعف براهين و تقريرهاي مختلف اين قاعده چيست؟ از طرفي، اشكالاتي نيز بر اين قاعده مطرح شده است كه با تكيه بر مباني حكمت متعاليه قابل دفع ميباشند. محقق دواني، اشكالي بر قاعده مطرح نموده است كه ملاصدرا بر اساس اصالت وجود و فروعات آن، به اشكال پاسخ داده است. اين پاسخ ميتواند زمينه‌ساز تقرير ديگري از قاعده شود كه در مقاله بدان پرداخته شده است. http://kherad.mullasadra.org/fa/Article/Download/23775